A systematic review of 15 randomised trials in 1161 pre- and postmenopausal women found animal proteins such as whey, meat and milk cut body fat more consistently than soy over 8-16 weeks, but mainly when combined with calorie restriction and exercise, and benefits of raising protein alone could not be confirmed.
What it shows: Systematic review of 15 RCTs (1161 women), but effects were strongly confounded by co-interventions like energy restriction and exercise, and results across trials were heterogeneous.Systematic review · FASEB J