Supplement database

The supplement aisle runs on overclaiming. These pages do the opposite: each one separates what’s claimed from what the human evidence actually shows, labelled by strength and cited. They’re grouped below by how good that evidence really is.

Well-supported

Well-supported
  • Beta-alanineWell-supported· human data

    Modestly boosts high-intensity efforts lasting roughly one to four minutes.

  • CaffeineWell-supported· human data

    A genuinely effective, well-studied performance and focus aid.

  • Creatine monohydrateWell-supported· human data

    The most-researched, best-evidenced supplement for strength and muscle.

  • ElectrolytesWell-supported· human data

    Genuinely useful for heavy, prolonged sweating — overkill as an everyday drink for most.

  • Whey proteinWell-supported· human data

    A convenient protein source that supports muscle when your total intake falls short.

Preliminary

Preliminary
  • AshwagandhaPreliminary· human data

    An adaptogen with early human data for stress and, more tentatively, strength.

  • Citrulline malatePreliminary· human data

    A popular pump ingredient with some, but inconsistent, performance evidence.

  • CollagenPreliminary· human data

    Emerging evidence for tendons, joints and skin — but a poor muscle-building protein.

  • MagnesiumPreliminary· human data

    Fixing a shortfall can help sleep and cramps; a boost when you're replete is weak.

  • Omega-3 (fish oil)Preliminary· human data

    Solid general-health rationale; the muscle and recovery benefits are still preliminary.

  • Vitamin DPreliminary· human data

    Correcting a deficiency matters; a performance boost if you're already replete is unproven.

Marketing claim

Marketing claim
  • Pre-workoutMarketing claim· human data

    A few proven ingredients wrapped in a lot of underdosed, unproven extras.

  • ZMAMarketing claim· human data

    The testosterone- and strength-boosting claims don't hold up in people who aren't deficient.